COMMENTARY: The Rio Grande Foundation is a nonpartisan organization, but like so many other New Mexicans we followed the recent election closely and were surprised by the “blue tsunami” that hit our state.
As a policy-driven organization, we look forward, not back. That said, the utter devastation of the GOP and most fiscally-conservative candidates on Election Day will make the 2019 Legislature and beyond quite interesting. We have a number of questions that we don’t know the answers to, but we hope will frame the policy discussion as we move forward:
• The gross receipts tax is a job-killing mess. Candidate Michelle Lujan Grisham pledged to address it, starting with naming a bipartisan tax commission to look at it. Will she really make tax reform a priority and will she get enough Democrats in the Legislature to get involved, or will the whole thing devolve into a push for higher taxes?
• Lujan Grisham supported marijuana legalization, and the House is more progressive than ever. Is there enough support in the Senate to legalize recreational pot?
• Speaking of the Senate, will Senate Finance Committee Chairman John Arthur Smith be able to stymie efforts to tap the “permanent fund” for universal pre-K, or will there be a compromise or capitulation? Also, will the Senate in general and Smith in particular stand firm against what seems likely to be a raft of tax-and-spending proposals that have been bottled up by Gov. Susana Martinez for the past eight years?
• We know that K-12 spending will rise dramatically, but by how much? With Democrats in control of everything they have tremendous leeway to shape New Mexico’s education system. How will they spend that money, and will they be able to actually improve our state’s struggling K-12 system?
• With “progressives” running the show in the House and having already attempted to ban new charter schools, are New Mexico’s charter schools in danger?
• Will Republicans unite to oppose big-spending and taxing plans? The House GOP won’t be able to exert itself on many policies with a massive disadvantage and a “progressive” majority led by Speaker Brian Egolf, but Senate Republicans could influence policies with a reconstituted “cowboy coalition.”
• Will Democrats succeed in eliminating the $50 million cap on film subsidies and increasing the state’s “renewable” mandate to 50 percent from the current (as of 2020) 20 percent requirement? Is a $12 minimum wage inevitable? What economic impact will these policies have on the state economy?
• Finally, will New Mexico’s oil boom continue? The state has benefited greatly from the boom in oil production in the Permian Basin, which has been sustained by high oil prices. Since Oct. 1 the price per barrel has dropped from the mid-$70s to below $60. Future oil prices are hard to predict and even harder to base budget on.
Declining oil prices are not the only concern. Land Commissioner-elect Stephanie Garcia-Richard is the first New Mexico land commissioner to have expressed hostility toward the oil and gas industry that funds this state’s economy and her office. Will she fulfill her anti-industry campaign rhetoric (which included banning fracking) or will she be willing to work with the industry while also advancing the cause of “renewables” and protecting state lands?
New Mexico has always been a pretty “blue” state. Gov. Martinez took a lot of heat for the sorry state of New Mexico’s economy even while Democrats in the Legislature prevented her from adopting most of her policy reforms (like “right to work” and education reforms). With the Democrats in total control and presumably in control of the coming redistricting process, is New Mexico the newest blue state like California?
Or if Democrats mismanage the budget, raise too many taxes, and things generally go poorly for Gov.-elect Lujan Grisham, will the pendulum swing back toward New Mexico being a “purple” state once again? And, if so, will Republicans/Libertarians/moderates be able to formulate a coherent strategy to take advantage of that overreach?
Paul Gessing is the president of New Mexico’s Rio Grande Foundation, an independent, non-partisan, tax-exempt research and educational organization dedicated to promoting prosperity for New Mexico based on principles of limited government, economic freedom and individual responsibility.
4 Replies to “Following ‘blue tsunami,’ what’s next for NM’s free-market movement?”
Thanks for bringing up the topic of oil prices. It has been something I have concerned about as it relates to the state revenues. Being a newcomer to NM I could use some education on the relationship of oil prices and state revenues. Coming from a trading background it hard to accept that if the state revenues of approximately 1/3 come from Oil & Gas that there is not a plan to hedge the risks of price declines to stabilize the revenue streams from these sources. Now the WTI benchmark is near $50.00 it would seem there would be more concern to conserve the revenues earned from higher prices. According to some research I have seen the demand for Oil is expected to peak in the next few years while substitute alternatives are expected to grow. The Michael Porter 5 forces are in play.
You have touched upon a complicated issue here. I can’t go deep into detail, but NM does have a reserve fund. Of course there are other funds and there is the “permanent fund” which is supposed to benefit future generations and the schools.
All that being said, when you are so dependent on oil and gas a sustained price drop will have negative ramifications for jobs and the state’s overall economic picture. Government can have all the reserves it wants, but what really matters is the economy outside of government and that is the challenge here. So, the answer is for policymakers to work to diversify the economy by making it more free market and generally attractive as a business destination. That has not happened and shows no sign of happening.
NM is about to experience a perfect storm of bad policies. The environmentalists will enact “keep it in the ground” laws that prevent fracking and will increase the RPS to at least 50%, probably 100%. Pre-K will get funded big time and higher ed spending will not get cut a penny. The minimum wage will increase to at least $12, probably $15 in Santa Fe,
And where will the Republicans be while this is going on? They’ll be talking about “all of the above” energy sourcing, raising the minimum to “only” $11.50, and going along with additional spending to “help educate our children.”
Libertarians and Independents are our only hope for NM. Without their votes Democrat Progressives have a free reign to do just about any thing they want. If more and more people are convinced the “socialist utopia” is a great idea then NM is in for some very hard times. Of course, the Democrats can over reach and push the political pendulum back but I am not optimistic. With so many illegals, poor and indoctrinated young people NM seems Hell bent on self destruction.