Making the Essentials More Expensive

In “Government and the Cost of Living: Income-Based vs. Cost-Based Approaches to Alleviating Poverty,” a new paper from the Cato Institute, Ryan Bourne explores an anti-poverty policy strategy focused on cutting the poor’s bills — not broadening and expanding welfare programs.

Bourne contrasts “income-based” strategies with “reforming existing government policies that raise the prices of basic goods and services and thereby hurt the poor through higher living costs.”

As the chart above reveals, people “in the bottom 20 percent of the income distribution tend to spend a much higher proportion than the rest of the population on ‘essential’ goods and services.” The opportunities for savings are substantial, because Bourne’s list of costly interventions is extensive: “land-use planning and zoning regulations,” sugar subsidies and protectionism, D.C.’s milk mess, the Renewable Fuel Standard, CAFE mandates, dealership-franchise laws, import tariffs on apparel, and occupational licensing. All deserve serious reform, if not full repeal.

Errors of Enchantment can’t think of a better way to make “essential” goods — and services — cheaper in New Mexico than tackling the perpetually rising rates of the gross receipts tax. Last month, Farmington became the latest community to hike its GRT, from 7.6250 percent to 8.2500 percent. (On July 1, Albuquerque’s GRT rose from 7.5000 percent to 7.8750 percent.)

The chart below depicts the growing GRT burden in the state’s seven largest municipalities, which contain 45.8 percent of New Mexico’s population. Rio Rancho saw the slightest rise, and Farmington — as of January 1, 2019 — the greatest.

Whether it’s the good or service itself, or the inputs required to produce the good or service, New Mexico’s GRT makes the state’s poor poorer. But don’t hold your breath waiting for leftists in the Land of Enchantment to lobby to weaken the levy’s sting.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.