Meaningless “basic income” experiments in Las Cruces

Evan many conservative thought leaders have been willing to consider the idea (called Universal basic income) of replacing welfare payments to the poor with cash payments. The idea is pretty simple: welfare programs have a bunch of hoops and phase-outs that can often disincentivize going from welfare to work. One problem (as other conservatives often point out) is that politicians are unwilling to eliminate the welfare programs and pay them out in a cash equivalent.

In recent years there have been experiments, supposedly with UBI concepts, but they never actually result in replacement of welfare with cash, they simply result in more cash. We critiqued a 2021 Santa Fe program along those lines.

Now, Las Cruces has gotten into the mix. A privately funded guaranteed basic income project allocated 330 families $500 per month and ended in January. Results haven’t been analyzed yet. Now, thanks to $1.7 million dollars of federal American Rescue Plan Act funding, multiple nonprofits in the Las Cruces community will provide $500 monthly payments over 18 months to 150 eligible Las Cruces families”

Will the results of these experiments mean anything? Sure, most people, especially those with low incomes, will gladly take an extra $500 annually, but unless the UBI is a replacement as opposed to a supplement for existing welfare programs it will be rather meaningless.

Interestingly, Mayor Ken Miyagishima, a Democrat, appears to be the only voice of reason in Las Cruces government. He said, “I hope it doesn’t just turn into, hey, I got this money, this is great. And okay, it ran out, so what am I going to do now?”

Universal Basic Income: The reasons why it's a terrible idea. – The Trailblazer

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

4 Replies to “Meaningless “basic income” experiments in Las Cruces”

  1. If, the funds are meant to help the really poor families. Then why not, lower the amount to $100per. Mo. That way you’re helping more people in the same m meaningless manner. I myself, would be glad to revive an extra $50 a month! I bet the governor, doesn’t go without dinner that often. If ever!

  2. If, this is the case and the funds are to help the really poor of las Cruces. Then why not, lower the 18mo. allotments to $100 per. mo. That way you’re helping more people in the same meaningless manner. As, the mayor calls it. A temporary, fix. Speaking as a citizen of Las Cruces, a veteran, and one of the many poor senior. I’d take $50 & be glad.

  3. Las Cruces can definitely benefit from this money it’s time that the people see that they are being looked after by our governor.. not just hearing about her staff getting very big bonuses her going on vacations left and right it’s time for us as residence of New Mexico be able to be part of that it’ll help put money back into the economy as well

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.