Using dying children to justify bigger government

Allen Sanchez represents CHI St. Joseph’s Children and the Catholic Church as a lobbyist in Santa Fe. He had an article in today’s Albuquerque Journal that I consider nothing short of outrageous in which he attempts to connect the deaths and abuse of dozens of New Mexico children over the last decade or so to the latest government “solution” to the problem which is tapping the permanent fund to create a system of home visits. He claims offhandedly that “home visiting programs have been proven to prevent child abuse,” but offers zero evidence for that statement.

Indeed, the only evidence Sanchez brings forth is a statement by Dr. Victor Strasburger, professor of pediatrics at the University of New Mexico, “Poverty seems to be the common denominator.” In other words, New Mexico’s lousy economy may be the issue, not some new government program he’s pushing (a point we’ve made in the past).

It all strikes me as, to quote Rahm Emmanuel “You never let a serious crisis go to waste. And what I mean by that it’s an opportunity to do things you think you could not do before.”

There is no doubt that New Mexico children face real problems (like the rest of the state). The liberal Voices for Children didn’t even include “home visits” as a factor in its report ranking 49th for children. That said, here is a partial list of all the myriad issues facing New Mexico kids that have NOTHING to do with yet another government program:

1) Poverty;
2) Breakdown of two parent family;
3) Welfare dependence;
4) Drug abuse;
5) Family culture of abuse;
6) Failing education system;
7) Failing economy/lack of jobs;
8) Social isolation;
9) Failing criminal justice system;
10) Lack of religious faith/participation

These are just a few of the very serious issues that impact New Mexico’s children. Some of them can be fixed rather easily by public policy reforms. Some of them are very difficult to address at all. What do you think? Any additions to the list? It is particularly troubling to me that Sanchez attempts to justify his preferred government program as a simple solution to what by all accounts is a very challenging and multi-faceted problem.

Image result for new mexico children killed

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

One Reply to “Using dying children to justify bigger government”

  1. The proposal to tap the permanent fund for early childhood education could have merit if it’s attached to a credible business case and backed by a coalition of reputable organizations. But I’m not about to vote for a blank check.

    Allen Sanchez and CHI St. Joseph’s have emerged as the face of this campaign, and Sanchez’ op-ed this morning makes me increasingly suspicious. In addition to its ethical repugnance, Sanchez’ piece was a self-serving pitch for his organization’s program — with the implication that CHI St. Joseph’s will be the primary beneficiary of $150 million a year.

    Is CHI St. Joseph’s getting any scrutiny? The organization clearly is well-funded enough to pay for the slick “New Mexico Truth” ad campaign. Are any government or watchdog organizations looking at CHI St. Joseph’s sources of funding, political activities or tax status?

    I have been concerned about the early childhood education proposal’s probable ineffectiveness and risk of further government government waste. Sanchez’ op-ed now makes me wonder about the potential for corruption.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.