Errors of Enchantment

The Feed

Grover Norquist and “No new taxes”

11.28.2011

I recently wrote about Grover Norquist and the blame he has taken in the media for the failure of the “SuperCommittee.” Interestingly-enough, 60 Minutes, which has done some really good stories recently, did a story on Grover and the “anti-tax” pledge:

Simply put, avoiding tax hikes is not a “silver bullet” for smaller government, but it is a starting point for holding politicians accountable. The battle for the next decade is to hold the line on taxes while getting spending under control and making “entitlement” programs financially-sustainable.

Is solar power cost effective? Not really.

11.26.2011

Liberal New York Times columnist Paul Krugman recently wrote a column touting the “fact” that solar-generated electrical power is now cost-effective. Perhaps Krugman has not seen the chart below:

To further explain why Krugman is simply ignoring reality, check out this excellent post from Todd Myers of the Washington Policy Center (our sister think tank in Washington State). Myers will be traveling to New Mexico to discuss his new book “Eco Fads” in February of 2012.

Comparing individual New Mexico schools

11.22.2011

It is difficult, given the lack of coherently-presented information, to understand how good or poor of a job various schools throughout New Mexico are doing. Performance comparison that takes into account students’ socio-economic backgrounds and historical improvement has not really been done. Well, thanks to the New Mexico Coalition of Charter Schools, it has now.

Check out the Coalition’s “School Dashboard.” It allows interested parents and the public to see how every public and charter school in the state is performing on the state’s Standards Based Assessment (the main standardized test administered by the state.

So far, data is only available for 2009 and 2011, but assuming that the data continues to be updated into the future, this report will give a good indicator of which schools are doing the job and which are not. Kudos to the New Mexico Coalition of Charter Schools for pushing both charter and traditional public schools further down the road to transparency and accountability!

“Supercommittee” failure and blaming Grover Norquist

11.21.2011

The so-called “Supercommittee” is done. Failed, kaput. The gulf between Democrats and Republicans was simply too great. Let the finger-pointing ensue. But who is to blame?

The left would point to anti-tax activist Grover Norquist and his “no new taxes” pledge for preventing Republicans from going along with Democratic demands to raise taxes. I agree that Grover has been very effective in fighting tax hikes and for this he should be celebrated, not derided.

After all, the $1.2 trillion in spending cuts that was supposed to be the target of the Supercommittee was less than this year’s deficit! And, as I’ve noted before, the size of the federal government has doubled (from $1.9 trillion to $3.7 trillion) since Clinton left office. Clearly, the “Supercommittee” needed to focus on spending cuts and, if Congress was allowed to further increase spending (absent Grover’s pledge) it would have done so.

So, thanks Grover for keeping tax hikes at bay. Now, we need to force Congress to allow the supposedly “automatic” cuts to happen.

Talking about Gov. Martinez’s tax reform proposals w/ Tax Foundation

11.19.2011

The Tax Foundation is one of the most prominent and oldest think tanks dedicated to tax and budget policy issues in Washington. With Gov. Martinez having discussed some recent tax policy ideas for the 2012 legislative session, I was pleased to have the opportunity to discuss the Rio Grande Foundation’s work on tax reform and our views on some of the reforms the Governor is considering. Listen to the 10 minute discussion here.

Kudos to the Clovis Schools

11.18.2011

As I wrote earlier this week, we at the Rio Grande Foundation have collected and released payroll documents for all of New Mexico’s 33 counties. We have also been collecting payroll documents from some of the largest school districts in the state.

In that process, I believe we played a role in APS’s laudable decision to release payroll information on its website.

But, some school districts like the Clovis Municipal Schools decided to take transparency to heart. We were very pleased that, upon receiving our information request, not only did Clovis comply, but they took it upon themselves to post payroll, past audits, and additional documents on their website. This proactive effort is exactly what we (and others) are hoping to spur among various government agencies throughout the state. We encourage other districts, counties, city governments, and institutions to take similar action.

60 Minutes: insider trading in Congress

11.17.2011

The following is an excellent story by the show 60 Minutes that details how Members of Congress use the information they are privy to as such to buy and sell stocks and other financial instruments:

Of course, if you read this blog, you’d know that New Mexico Sen. Jeff Bingaman has become a very wealthy man based on his time in Congress. He’s by no means the only one in Congress to have done so.

Memo to the “Occupy” movement: “The real 1% reside in Washington (or at least the DC suburbs)!”

Sorry, Train Woes Can’t be Fixed

11.16.2011

The Santa Fe New Mexican recently editorialized, albeit half-heartedly, in favor of keeping the Rail Runner chugging down the tracks. In doing so, they made the brilliant observation that “The key to making the Rail Runner a success is finding the money to operate it.” Duh, if money were no object, then the world would be a very different place and we’d all have flying cars and not need a train anyway.

The paper also stated the old nostrum that “mass transit never makes a profit, and it seldom breaks even.” Even that is simply not true. Check this link out. Some systems in Asia do more than break even and nearly all systems do better in terms of fare box recovery than the Rail Runner which has a ratio of 13%.

Of course, the line about road subsidies was then brought up, but, even if certain roads in rural areas are subsidized, what are we to do, not have them? The fact is that no community could survive without roads while most survive just fine without passenger rail playing a major role in the transportation mix. And, of course, as this chart shows (on the first actual page), transit and rail receive subsidies far in excess of those allocated to roads.

For more information on the Rail Runner’s disturbing finances and what to do about it, go here.

And, as a bit of an aside, I found the comments of one of the authors of the book “Freakonomics” on libertarian transportation analyst Randal O’Toole quite interesting.

Join FreedomWorks and Rio Grande Foundation for two great activism events

11.15.2011

Join the national free market organization FreedomWorks, the Rio Grande Foundation, and local tea party groups for two exciting events in New Mexico. These two events will give you the opportunity to meet local activists, learn about the issues, and develop your grassroots organizing skills.

The first event, a strategy lunch with FreedomWorks staff, will take place on Tuesday, December 6th at the Vernon’s Hidden Valley Steakhouse (6855 4th St NW Los Ranchos de Albuquerque, NM 87107) from 1 to 4 PM. Treat yourself to a good meal while listening and learning some of the strategies and techniques of grassroots organizing. This lunch will also give you the opportunity to meet other tea party groups and leaders which will certainly be pivotal in helping you expand your group.

Our second event, a training session with FreedomWorks staff, will take place on Wednesday, December 7th at the Albuquerque Marriot (2101 Louisiana Blvd NE Albuquerque, NM 87110, USA) from 6-9PM. Join FreedomWorks campaign team and the Rio Grande Foundation as we discuss some of the following topics: Campaigns 101, building and maintaining your group, organizing for 2012, and new media and FreedomConnector 101. This event will be a great opportunity to meet other activists and learn some new techniques that will help as we approach the 2012 season.

With countless issues facing New Mexico and the 2012 elections just around the corner we look forward to seeing you at these two great events. Please RSVP to David Spielman by email at dspielman@freedomWorks.org or by phone at 202-942-7607.

Thanks and we look forward to seeing you at these two events!

For Freedom

David Spielman

Campaigns Coordinator, FreedomWorks

Event Details:

What: Lunch with FreedomWorks and local tea party groups

When: Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Where: Vernon’s Hidden Valley Steakhouse (6855 4th St NW Los Ranchos de Albuquerque, NM 87107)

Time: 1:00-4:00PM

What: Grassroots Training with FreedomWorks staff and the Rio Grande Foundation

When: Wednesday, December 7, 2011

Where: Albuquerque Marriot (2101 Louisiana Blvd NE Albuquerque, NM 87110, USA)

Time: 6:00-9:00PM

Who wants “industrialized” education?

11.14.2011

As I write at NMPolitics.net today, it is certainly not the Rio Grande Foundation and other reformers that want such one-size-fits-all models perpetuated. Some (who seem perfectly happy with New Mexico being 49th in the nation) have argued as much. A free market (or at least reforms that move in that direction) in education inherently means increased diversity, improved quality, and the end to “cookie-cutter” educational models dreamed up by social planners.

2011 New Mexico County Payroll

11.14.2011

The Electric Vehicle Mirage

11.11.2011

It is worth noting that electronic vehicles are not a new technology. In fact, as energy expert Robert Bradley noted in his presentation to the Rio Grande Foundation audience yesterday, Henry Ford hoped to collaborate with Thomas Edison to build an electric car nearly 100 years ago.

Curiously-enough, I ran across this review of the Nissan Leaf electric car from Consumers Reports. Driving one of these contraptions around New York City is obviously problematic from the author’s comments — constant worries over battery life, inability to use heat or A/C. Could you imagine driving one of these in New Mexico with our open spaces and weather extremes?

Of course, people can and should be able to buy whatever car they want, no matter how poorly it operates, but the Obama Administration’s $2 billion in spending on electric vehicles (and that’s just the start of the federal subsidies) means that we are all on the hook for this waste. I’m not against electric cars, but they (and any other technologies) need to compete in a free and open marketplace.

H/T Paul Chesser

But that’s the problem! (Paid legislators “represent their government employers”)

11.10.2011

I found the article in today’s Albuquerque Journal by former Rep. Barbara Perea Casey to be interesting. After discussing the supposed hardships of being in the Legislature and the court case that enabled New Mexico teachers to serve in the Legislature after they were defined as not being “state” employees, she makes some rather enlightening comments about the role of government school teachers in the Legislature. Perea Casey writes:

It is my personal opinion that legislators who are also educators are providing a distinct and unique service to the school districts that employ them. In the case of Stapleton, she continues to perform her job duties.

It is sad that some of the school board members do not realize her worth in terms of how much bad legislation she can stop, or how much influence she has in education advocacy, especially in her powerful position of majority whip. It is also unfortunate that she is not viewed as a supporter for Albuquerque Public Schools, because that is what she is.

So, government school educators serving in the Legislature are not supposed to serve their constituents (or that is an unmentioned afterthought), rather, they are naturally supposed to align themselves with the interests of their employers by stopping “bad” legislation. Presumably this means vouchers, school choice, budget cuts, and anything else that would undermine the power and financial interests of the government school monopoly.

So, not only is government education politically-sympathetic and not only do they have lobbyists, but they also have legislators who are paid by the schools (read taxpayers) to be in Santa Fe. Pretty sweet deal! Needless to say, legislators who run their own businesses or hold down private-sector jobs don’t get this perk. Government begetting bigger, less-accountable government is why former AG Hal Stratton attempted to stop the practice.

Time to competitively contract ABQ trash collection

11.09.2011

In case you haven’t seen it yet, KOB TV has an excellent story on the shenanigans taking place among our city trash collectors:

First, kudos to Mayor Berry for having the guts to do this investigation. However, as we have previously mentioned, the City of Albuquerque could save significant taxpayer resources by contracting out solid waste collection to a private company. Rather than simply doing this, the City should solicit competitive bids from public and private entities and go with the best, lowest-cost option in a process called “competitive sourcing.”

If a private company or government workers operating under a contract were misbehaving, the taxpayers and customers would not be the one paying the bill.

Excellent article on the Rail Runner (and something on Amtrak too)

11.08.2011

Barry Massey of the AP had one of the more balanced and informative stories you’ll find on New Mexico’s foundering Rail Runner.  As transportation analyst Wendell Cox notes, “there is almost a worship of rail.” I couldn’t agree more.

Speaking of rail worship, defenders of Amtrak are pulling out all the stops to preserve the $1.3 billion in annual subsidies that system receives. The chart’s creator (available at the link) attempts to increase the costs of automobiles to make it seem even with Amtrak. Things like “lost tax revenue” and “transportation diversity” come down in Amtrak’s favor.

The fact is that America’s passenger rail system would be better off if the federal government simply privatized it. Getting rid of costly union contracts and money-losing routes while focusing resources in heavily-populated areas would allow passenger rail to turn a profit and serve more people. Instead, Congress is strangling passenger rail service by keeping it on perpetual life support.

Yes, education must be first in 2012

11.07.2011

New Mexico Sen. Pete Campos wrote recently in the Albuquerque Journal about the need for K-12 education to be a top priority for the Legislature in the upcoming session. I couldn’t agree more with that (as I’ve written recently), but in reading the article, I discovered that our methods are far different.

To make a long story short, Campos wants to dramatically-increase spending on a variety of early childhood, public health, and government education programs. He does propose some ideas that won’t necessarily increase spending — like “strengthening curriculum and aligning it with employment trends…and manufacturing” These are nice ideas, but New Mexico doesn’t have much more money to spend. Even if it did, I’m not convinced that much of what Campos wants to do would really result in educational improvement.

Instead of more funding, we have repeatedly discussed several proposals (here and here) that would result in greater school choice and improved results. Unfortunately, when it comes to our schools, it always seems that more money is the mantra, even though we’ve already been there, done that.

“Supercommittee” Cuts Must Happen

11.06.2011

Media reports have been regularly lamenting the debacle that is the Congressional “Supercommittee.” This was supposed to be okay as Congress would then be “forced” to cut $1.1 trillion over the next ten years through a process known as “sequester.” Of course, these are not real cuts, but are instead cuts relative to the baseline budget as you can see from the chart below:

But, members on both sides of the aisle are now saying the “cuts” may not even happen. The main concern is defense spending, but the reality is that when the rubber hits the road, neither party in Washington really wants to cut spending if it means cutting their pet programs. So, America will slide further towards Greece and Republicans will be giving Obama a free ticket to a second term by showing themselves to not be serious about spending (but we’ve said this all before)….

And, yes, contrary to the views of many, America can stand to cut defense spending:

Albuquerque Public Schools: Timing is everything

11.05.2011

Albuquerque Public Schools have been in the news a lot this week. First, they made the decision to make employee payroll information publicly available on their website. Click here to find it. Notably, we at the Rio Grande Foundation had been in the process of attempting to obtain salary data from it and other school districts around the state (as this letter illustrates). I’d also complained about their lack of compliance with the request mere days before APS went ahead and posted the salary data.

Which leads me to the other major issue out there regarding APS this week and that is the decision to change district rules to allow administration to pay administrators while they are serving in the Legislature. Teachers are already allowed to continue receiving pay while they serve.

So, I think it was interesting timing that APS released the salary data in the first place. I’m pleased by the District’s move and think RGF had a great deal to do with it (they’ll never admit it). Also, I think the positive, heavily-publicized decision was timed to cover the district for ignoring its own clearly-stated rules on paying administrators to serve in the Legislature. Of course, I don’t blame them. Who wouldn’t want to have what amount to paid lobbyists working for you in Santa Fe (in addition to those you already pay)? It is just one more example of the vast difference (and advantages) available if you work for the government in this state rather than the private sector.

How is NM doing on virtual education?

11.04.2011

The Rio Grande Foundation has been New Mexico’s leading proponent of virtual education. Notably, New Mexico is a state that has done fairly well in the area of promoting virtual schooling, but like nearly all states, we have a ways to go before we are really maximizing the potential of these new technologies.

The group “Digital Learning Now” has been started by former Gov’s Jeb Bush (R-FL) and Bob Wise (D-WV) to push state policymakers to move forward on digital education and virtual schooling. To this end, they have issued a report card for each of the 50 states. The report card allows users to pair various states, so I have paired New Mexico and Florida (one of the nationwide leaders in virtual education) here.

Higher numbers indicate that the state is achieving a greater number of goals associated with virtual schooling. New Mexico certainly doesn’t perform at the level of Florida and Arizona, but we do okay in the report.

Read the full explanation of the 10 elements of high quality digital learning and how policymakers can work to improve them.

Incoherent, Clueless Occupy Movement (and a home-grown reaction to it)

11.04.2011

Much has been made over the “fact” that the Occupy movement is generally non-violent. And, while many of the protesters may have condemned the outright violence that occurred in Oakland, the same protesters have also shut down the port of Oakland. I’m sorry, but shutting down a port is not “non-violent.” On the international scale, a blockade is considered to be an act of war. On the micro level, if I barricade you in your own house and stop you from leaving, this is an act of aggression. This is aside from the fact that shutting down the port will inevitably cost jobs and harm the so-called 99% of us who benefit from free trade and the economic activity associated with the port.

Recently, for a Reason.TV video, Peter Schiff went out and tried to have a discussion with some protesters in New York. He too found that they were intellectually inconsistent, often ignorant, and all over the place when it comes to an agenda.

Lastly, to counteract the “Occupy” movement and its muddled/socialistic messages, the New Mexico Conservative Republicans are putting on a “teach in” at UNM next Tuesday, November 8. I’ll be taking part and information is as follows:

CONSERVATISM AND THE U.S. CONSTITION: ANTIDOTES TO TYRANNY

University of New Mexico
Tuesday, November 8, from 11 AM to 1:30 PM, in the SUB Atrium

11:00 AM – Introduction
11:10 AM – Donald Gluck, UNM Conservative Republicans
– CONSERVATISM: PRINCIPLES & HISTORY
11:40 AM – Conrad James, Representative House District 24
– GOVERNMENT POLICY & THE FINANCIAL MELTDOWN
12:10 PM – Greg Sowards, Republican Candidate for U.S. Senate
– RESTORING THE PROMISE OF PROSPERITY FOR NEW MEXICO
12:30 PM – Mike Blessing, President Libertarian Party of Bernalillo County
– CAPITALISM & MERCANTILISM
1:00 PM – Paul Gessing, President Rio Grande Foundation
– THE U.S. CONSTITUTION

Florida reforms are (still) working

11.03.2011

The latest National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) scores are out. Remember that the Florida Model is based on that state’s success in improving reading scores among all students, but especially poor ones. There is some useful data to point out regarding Florida and New Mexico. I’ve posted two charts (thanks to Matt Ladner and Jay Greene). First, the chart below shows 4th grade NAEP reading scores for free and reduced lunch kids (a measure of poverty). Notice that Florida’s poor kids perform 5th best in the nation. Among states, New Mexico is 3rd worst (thank God for California!).

Interestingly, New Mexico’s educational under-performance is not limited to the poor. Middle and upper income whites perform relatively poorly in our state while Florida is again among the best-performing states in the nation.

As I’ve written before, many in the New Mexico Legislature seem all too happy with the status quo.