Errors of Enchantment

The Feed

Tipping Point New Mexico: now on Youtube!

02.08.2021

The Rio Grande Foundation’s Tipping Point New Mexico podcast is one of the best ways for people to keep track of what is happening in New Mexico and its important political and policy issues.

But it is not “just” a podcast. We ALSO upload video footage of the interviews and discussions to Youtube.

Here is a recent conversation with site selector John Boyd.

Here is the most recent conversation on “news of the week” with Wally Drangmeister:

And, here is a recent conversation with Fred Nathan of Think New Mexico:

 

Bill Richardson’s tax cuts WERE a success!

02.04.2021

It has now become an article of faith on the left in New Mexico that Gov. Bill Richardson’s 2003 tax cuts were a failure. Several tax hike bills including (at least) two that would raise New Mexico’s personal income tax rate have been introduced this session including:

SB 56: Sen. Bill O’Neill’s bill to increase New Mexico’s top personal income tax rate to 8.2% (the bill was heard in Senate Tax on Thursday);

SB 89: Sen. Bill Tallman’s bill to increase New Mexico’s top personal income tax rate to 6.5%;

You MAY recall that the Richardson cuts took New Mexico’s top income tax rate from 8.2% down to 4.9% over 5 years where it was until 2019. The cuts ALSO cut capital gains tax rates in half. These were REAL tax cuts and they passed the Democrat-controlled House without a single dissenting vote and passed the Senate by a margin of 39 to 2 and were signed into law on Valentine’s Day, 2003.

Richardson and Were Richardson’s tax cuts REALLY a failure? No. In fact, none other than the liberal “fact checking” site PolitiFact said that Richardson’s job creation claims (made in advance of his 2008 reelection campaign) were “mostly true.”

As PolitiFact noted in 2007,

Statistics from the Bureau of Labor Statistics indicate that New Mexico gained 75,800 jobs from December 2002 to July 2007, which is slightly lower than Richardson’s claim.

As our friends at FactCheck.org note in this article , Richardson has consistently cited the higher number, even when the actual number was lower.

For our ruling, however, we’ll rely on the current 75,800 and call it mostly true.

PolitiFact further quoted none other than NMSU economist (one of NM’s top economic gurus) Jim Peach approvingly.

Peach said Richardson’s tax incentives and income tax cuts have created a favorable atmosphere for business that is a stark change from the state’s mentality in the mid-1970s, when state officials refused to provide help to a promising young company named Microsoft.

The climate here has changed considerably since then, Peach said. Bill Richardson has been a big part of that. He’s not the whole story, but he’s been a big part of it.

The fact is that if Richardson were governor today he would be too conservative for New Mexico’s Democratic Party on both guns and taxes.

 

Tomorrow, Senate committees consider two bad bills and a House committee looks at a pro-small business bill

02.04.2021

Tomorrow will be another busy day in the Roundhouse. Two bad bills will go before Senate committees and a refreshingly good bill will be under consideration in a House committee.

SJR 3 will appear before the Senate Rules Committee in a meeting starting at 9 AM. This bill would lead to a ballot proposal amending the state constitution to include provisions for “environmental rights” and allow for private right of action.

SB 148 will appear in a Senate Education Committee meeting, which also starts at 9 AM. SB 148 would create a “diversity commission” to implement policies to advance “diversity, equity, and excellence” in New Mexico public schools.

HB 164 would lower costs for restaurants and customers by gradually increasing the number of liquor licenses in circulation. HB 164 goes before the House Commerce and Economic Development Committee. That meeting starts at 1:30 PM.

All webcasts can be accessed here, and you can join the House committee Zoom meeting here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to both Senate bills and in favor of the House bill, which you can read below.

SJR 3 Testimony

SB 148 Testimony

HB 164 Testimony

HB 139 to give legislators a seat at table in emergencies moves forward

02.04.2021
HB 139 introduced by Rep. Greg Nibert is a top priority for the Rio Grande Foundation and should be for anyone who cares about separation of powers in New Mexico government.
On February 3 it passed the House State Government, Elections, and Indian Affairs Committee on a bi-partisan basis. Here are the votes (you can find the emails at the link above (bottom of the page).

 

For:
Rep. D. Wonda Johnson
Rep. Daymon Ely (Sponsor)
Rep. Doreen Gallegos
Rep. Greg Nibert (Sponsor)
Rep. Kristina Ortez
Rep. Bill Rehm
Rep. Martin Zamora

 

Against:
Rep. Georgene Louis
Rep. Gail Chasey

 

The next step is House Judiciary Committee where Gail Chasey is the Chair and can be reached at: gail@gailchasey.com. She needs to hear from those who support this basic good government measure. You can find the emails of all committee members here.
Image result for new mexico roundhouse locked down

Tipping Point NM episode 272: John Boyd – Site Selection during COVID-19 and Beyond

02.04.2021

John Boyd is a site selector who splits his time between Florida and New Jersey. He is familiar with New Mexico and its economy and was interviewed for the Tipping Point New Mexico podcast on April 9, 2020 in the early days of the COVID 19 pandemic. 

On this episode, John shares updates on what is happening in site selection and where business and human capital investment is moving as we move through and beyond COVID. Paul and John then discuss what New Mexico’s elected leaders can and should do to build on the existing assets of New Mexico.

Image result for john boyd site selection

Tracking New Mexico School District Reopening

02.04.2021

The Rio Grande Foundation has long called for basic education reforms that would empower parents and families when it comes to education resources including school choice. But, with the onset of COVID 19 and many districts moving to “virtual only” models, we have joined the Centers for Disease Control and many others in calling for students to return to their classrooms.

We will be tracking announced school reopenings under Gov. Lujan Grisham’s latest orders which call for hybrid learning for ALL students to begin on February 8. Check this space for updates. We gleaned this information from various district and news websites. If you have new info please let us know at: info@riograndefoundation.org

This information was last updated on February 22. 

District Date
Alamogordo Secondary – Feb. 16, Elementary – Feb. 22
Albuquerque Virtual only through year-end
Artesia Feb. 8
Bloomfield Some primary students in hybrid already, Secondary – Feb. 16
Carlsbad Feb. 8
Central Secondary – Feb. 16
Cloudcroft Primary already in-person, Secondary – Feb. 9
Clovis K-12 is now in hybrid learning
Cuba Remote through March 5
Estancia Secondary – Feb. 8
Farmington Primary already hybrid, 6th, 9th graders – Feb 8, Other secondary Feb. 16
Fort Sumner Middle, High school – Feb. 8
Gallup-McKinley All grades — Feb. 9
Hobbs Elementary – Feb. 8, 6th, 9th, 10th grade – Feb. 11-12, all students – Feb. 16
Las Cruces One high school open for hybrid, other 3 high schools will open March 4th, middle/elementary schools students will return March 1
Las Vegas Will remain virtual throughout the rest of the school year
Magdalena 6th-12th grade – Feb. 8
Portales All grades — Feb. 9
Rio Rancho Elementary students have been in hybrid model. 6-12 return in hybrid on Feb. 22.
Roswell Elementary students return on the 16th, 6th and 9th graders on the 18th, and all secondary grades on the 22nd
Santa Fe All grades — Feb. 22
Silver Middle, High school – Feb. 15-18
Truth or Consequences All students Feb. 16
Tucumcari All students Feb. 8

Sen. Stewart: People ARE leaving (or they’re not coming to) NM

02.03.2021

A long-shot piece of legislation (actually constitutional amendment SJR 15) introduce in the 2021 legislative session would allow counties that wish to get out of the State of New Mexico to do so.

While its sponsor, Sen. Cliff Pirtle (R-Roswell) has no illusions of passage, it was written up in the Albuquerque Journal and generated some waves with Sen. pro tem Mimi Stewart (D-Albuquerque) saying, “If you like Texas better, just pack up your bags and move – it’s not that far.”

The reality is that it’s not that easy for average citizens to leave family, friends, and jobs to move to another State. What is more likely is that people never show up in the first place while a relatively small number do indeed leave when jobs and other opportunities become available.

Census Bureau data of course track this. Over the decade from 2010 to 2019 it is clear that people are taking Stewart’s advice and are moving to New Mexico’s more-economically-free neighbors, some of which compete with New Mexico’s ample geographical and weather attributes which are indeed hard to compete with.

Even Oklahoma which (unlike Texas) has an income tax and is not nearly as “enchanting” as New Mexico from the perspectives of weather or geography, grew THREE TIMES faster than New Mexico last decade.

It’s always worth noting that New Mexico sticks out like a sore thumb in terms of economic freedom on the Fraser Institute’s annual index. And, while partisan Democrats may note that for much of the decade in question New Mexico had a Republican Governor, the Legislature remained at least partially controlled by Democrats the entire time and thus Republicans couldn’t actually change many public policies.

Tipping Point NM episode 271: COVID-19 Policy, Biden’s Energy Policy, Medicaid, Freedom Index and more

02.03.2021

On this week’s podcast conversation:

Apparently, not everyone was consulted by MLG on her back to school order. 

The number of active COVID cases is MUCH higher than it was for most of the time the schools were on lockdown. 

Good news. More counties are moving from red to yellow.

Under what logic can Top Golf open but not Cliffs or Hinkle Family Fun Center?

Biden’s energy crackdown isn’t just for 60 days. But, as discussed on the podcast recently, Kathleen Sgamma’s Western Energy Alliance has indeed filed a lawsuit

New Mexico is #1 in Medicaid recipients. MLG’s old business partner Rep. Deborah Armstrong (and seeming Medicaid profiteer) wants to levy a tax on insurance policies to fund additional welfare. 

Wally and Paul discuss some good bills this session. 

They further address a few bad bills including one on private prison prohibition and another on mandatory solar panels and electric vehicle charging stations on new homes.

Mandatory sick leave vs. tax incentives.

Watch EoE for details and regular updates during the virtual session.

NM unemployment rate jumps as economy locks down in November. 

Finally, Paul and Wally remind listeners to use the Foundation’s Freedom Index and check www.ErrorsofEnchantment.com as bills move through the process.

Virgin Galactic: closer to disaster than we knew

02.02.2021

Rio Grande Foundation has long opposed the New Mexico Spaceport. The facility, which opened nearly a decade ago and has yet to be used for its intended purpose (space tourism) was tailor-made for one company: Virgin Galactic.

Unfortunately, Virgin Galactic has put together what can only be described as a spotty safety record (and that’s before the company launches its first space tourist). We knew about the dead test pilot back in 2014. And recently the company had to abort a test launch because the engine failed to ignite. Now, according to revelations made in a soon-to-be-printed book, the company narrowly averted disaster back in February of 2019.

According to the Washington Post, Todd Ericson, a test pilot who also served as a vice president for safety and test said, “The structural integrity of the entire stabilizer was compromised (during the test), I don’t know how we didn’t lose the vehicle and kill three people.”

The Post article further notes that: the regulations governing private space companies are relatively loose — the Federal Aviation Administration ensures the safety of people and property on the ground, but there is merely an “informed consent” standard for the passengers, who need only acknowledge the risks as if they were skydiving or bungee jumping.

RGF’s Paul Gessing interviewed private space expert and proprietor of the website Parabolic Arc, Doug Messier, on two separate occasions about ongoing issues at Spaceport America for the Tipping Point NM podcast here and here. Messier raised safety concerns about Virgin Galactic’s technology during both interviews.

Virgin Galactic's VSS Unity craft during a supersonic flight test in May 2018.

House Labor Committee considers minimum wage increase bill today

02.02.2021

The House Labor, Veterans’, and Military Affairs Committee will meet today at 2 P.M. HB 110, a phased minimum wage increase, is on the schedule. It would raise the minimum wage across New Mexico to $15 by 2025 . This bill also requires the minimum wage to rise with the Consumer Price Index after 2025.

You can watch the committee meeting webcast here, or join the Zoom meeting here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to the bill which you can read here.

Minimum Wage Stock Illustrations – 361 Minimum Wage Stock Illustrations,  Vectors & Clipart - Dreamstime

Tipping Point New Mexico Episode: 270 Fred Nathan of Think New Mexico

02.01.2021

On this week’s Tipping Point interview Paul sits down with Fred Nathan of Think New Mexico. Think New Mexico is another policy think tank that works in New Mexico. They describe themselves as “A results-oriented think tank whose mission is to improve the lives of all New Mexicans.”

Fred and Paul discuss the organization’s past successes often working in tandem with the Rio Grande Foundation. For starters, Paul and Fred speak candidly about the security issues around the Roundhouse and the challenges of the unique 60-day “virtual” session. They also discuss grocery taxes and issues that cropped up over that issue since the onset of COVID 19.

Furthermore, they discuss Social Security taxation and efforts to limit or repeal that.

Finally, they have some disagreement over Think New Mexico’s latest proposal which would place a lower cap on various lending services in New Mexico.

Tune in to this interesting and informative conversation!

Fred Nathan

Seriously, if Top Golf can open, what about Cliffs, Hinkle, and many more?

02.01.2021

People who know the Rio Grande Foundation know that Paul Gessing enjoys playing golf. We made it clear that re-opening shuttered golf courses was a no-brainer early on in COVID. But, we (along with Mayor Keller) opposed over-generous subsidies for Top Golf.

But, now that the place is apparently going to open to the public THIS FRIDAY. And, in addition to appreciating having another OPEN entertainment amenity in the Albuquerque area, it is good when ANY business can open in our City, even those receiving subsidies.

But, ask yourself: how is hitting range balls in a stall any COVID safer than riding a roller coaster or playing at an open water area? As noted in my Albuquerque Journal column on the subject a vast majority of states across the nation have opened amusement parks.

So, if Top Golf can really open, I’m sure Cliffs and Hinkle will open as well, right? NOTE: Gessing has been to a few Top Golf facilities. Like most outdoor entertainment options you can make it COVID safe or unsafe depending on numerous factors.

Coronavirus: Topgolf closes all locations across the U.S.

Senate Conservation Committee considers two bad bills on Tuesday

01.29.2021

On Tuesday, February 2nd, the Senate Conservation Committee will meet to consider SB 67 and SB 132, both of which push a “green” agenda and send the costs to New Mexicans. SB 67 requires all new power generation plants to be 100% renewable, while SB 132 mandates all new home constructions to include solar panels.

The meeting starts at 9 A.M. and you can watch the webcast here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to both bills, which you can read below.

SB 67 Testimony

SB 132 Testimony

House Commerce committee considers one bad bill and one good bill

01.28.2021

The House Commerce and Economic Development Committee meets tomorrow, Friday the 29th, at 1:30 PM. They will consider two bills relating to paid sick and family leave. The bad bill, HB 38, requires employers to provide paid family and medical leave, while the good bill, HB 134, provides incentives for employers to provide family-friendly policies but does not mandate them.

You can watch the committee webcast here, or join the Zoom meeting here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to HB 38 and in support of HB 134.

We’re number one…in Medicaid (welfare) recipients

01.28.2021

With everything going on in the Legislature and the Biden Administration’s attack on oil and gas, it would be easy to miss the fact that New Mexico is now the MOST reliant state in the entire nation when it comes to the welfare program known as Medicaid.

According to the Albuquerque Journal, an astonishing 43% of all New Mexicans were enrolled in the program statewide as of November

“The federal government provides $4.76 for every dollar in state general funds spent on the program, up from $3.65 pre-pandemic. That equation is providing the state with an additional $385 million.”

Medicaid levels are driven by the generosity of state policies and our impoverished status. HB 122 which has been introduced by Rep. Deborah Armstrong in the 2021 Legislature would impose a new tax on private health insurance in order to fund ADDITIONAL welfare programs in health care.

The Line: Should All New Mexicans Be Able To Sign Up For Medicaid? - New Mexico In Focus

Senate Education committee considers several bad bills tomorrow

01.28.2021

The Senate Education Committee will meet tomorrow, Friday the 29th, at 9 A.M. Several bad bills will be under consideration, including SB 31, which requires a school nurse in every school district in the state, SB 63, which requires all new schools constructed to include solar panels, and SB 110, which raises contributions to educators’ healthcare plans.

You can watch the committee webcast here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to these bills. You can read our statements below.

SB 31 Testimony

SB 63 Testimony

SB 110 Testimony

Bad Bill ending contractor-operated prisons enters committee today

01.28.2021

The House Consumer and Public Affairs Committee will discuss one of the worst bills proposed this legislative session, *HB 40, in a meeting today, Thursday the 28th. The meeting starts at 1:30 P.M.

The bill would ban the use of contractor-operated prisons in New Mexico. Studies have shown that these prisons are less expensive for the state and can produce much better outcomes for both inmates and communities than public prisons.

You can watch the committee meeting webcast here, or join the Zoom meeting here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to *HB 40.

On return to school and APS

01.28.2021

Gov. Lujan Grisham rather suddenly this week announced that New Mexico school districts would be able to return students at all grade levels to the classroom for “hybrid” learning. That means 50% in-person and 50% “virtual.”

We welcome this news and believe it is long-overdue based on numerous studies of the issue. And, while we are certainly not going to question the Gov.’s decision or motivation, it is certainly worth asking why most New Mexico schools remained closed from March of 2020 all the way until now while the number of active cases has only recently declined from statewide highs. The following case chart is from the WorldoMeters COVID tracking website.

The move to reopen schools at this very moment (immediately after a new President of her own party has taken office) is just one of many perplexing details.

Of course Albuquerque Public Schools has said that it WILL NOT be opening  on March 8. The leading obstacle is the unions which has been the case across the nation. To be fair to APS it appears that Lujan Grisham did not consult many districts or anyone outside her inner circle before making her decision. This lack of transparency marked by sudden policy shifts has been an ongoing problem throughout the pandemic.

Finally, while teachers shouldn’t be FORCED into classrooms, the “one-size-fits-all” problem inherent in our education system is the core problem here. Willing teachers and willing students could and should have returned to in-person learning months ago. If APS had a financial incentive to serve families and students rather than being a government-sponsored monopoly, this would be the case.

Mandatory Paid Sick Leave bill hits House committee tomorrow

01.27.2021

Mandatory paid sick leave has surfaced once again, but this time it is being proposed in Santa Fe, not just in the Albuquerque City Council. The bill, *HB 37 has been referred to the House Labor, Veterans’, and Military Affairs Committee which will discuss the bill in a meeting on Thursday, January 28th. The meeting starts at 2 P.M.

You can watch the webcast here, or join the Zoom meeting here.

The Rio Grande Foundation submitted testimony in opposition to the bill.

Update on New York Paid Sick Leave Policy | HR Works

Best bills of 2021 Legislature so far

01.27.2021

HB 139: Terminates Gov.’s emergency declarations after 90 days unless extension approved by the Legislature;

HB 8: Allows home liquor delivery and “liberalizes” license rules;

HB 26: Disallows “greenfield” developments from TIDD’s;

HB 33: Authorizes NM livestock board to inspect meat;

HB 49: Exempt Social Security from taxation;

HB 177: Allows for sale of certain foods produced in home kitchens;

HJR 6: Terminates declaration of emergency by Gov. after 90 days unless Legislature approves extension;

HJR 7: Allows for parents of New Mexico students to use state education dollars for the school of their choice;

*SB 2: Waives liquor license fees for 2021;

SB 6: Allows home liquor delivery and “liberalizes” license rules;

SB 78: Exempts Social Security from income tax;

SB 87: Prohibits retaliation based on IPRA requests;

SB 98: Requires economic impact reports on incentive programs;

 

Tipping Point New Mexico Episode 269: Back to School, 60 Day Leasing Ban, Good, Bad and Ugly Bills at Legislature

01.27.2021

On this week’s episode, Paul and Wally discuss the fact that New Mexico schools will soon reopen in a hybrid format. This is good news, but Wally and Paul do have questions. Other “blue” states have reopened as well and the Lobos and Aggies sports teams have been allowed to come back to NM, but what about football and other fall high school sports?

Biden oil leasing ban on federal lands 60 days; Shocking how quickly that came about & Deb Haaland isn’t even sworn in yet.

Paul wants to put some facts on the table as the session rolls forward.

RGF has a day in court defending free speech.

Paul and Wally go through some of the worst bills introduced SO FAR in the 2021 session. House and Senate listed here. Paul talks about the challenges of testifying and citizen involvement in the session.

RGF’s Freedom Index is tracking votes right now. 

Will students return to classrooms…by next fall?

01.25.2021

Teacher unions nationwide have been the leading opponents of in-person learning. The ongoing debate in Chicago is the most high-profile place where unions are pushing HARD against returning to classrooms. There has not been much debate on this in New Mexico, but non-unionized districts have been more inclined to return to hybrid learning whereas union-heavy districts have stayed with remote learning.  

The paragraphs below are taken directly from a New York Times article which details the Biden Administration’s efforts to get students back to class and union efforts to push back. There are even concerns about returning to classrooms THIS FALL. 

UPDATE: Shortly after this post was written Gov. MLG “reopened” schools to 50% hybrid schooling, but she left the “final decision” open to districts. That’s a welcome development and we’re confident that rural districts can get started with opening. APS has already said they will not return on the 8th of Feb. and we’ll just see about other big, union-dominated districts.